LEVEL 1: BEYOND SMILEY SHEETS (REACTION)

Traditionally, Level 1: Reaction evaluates how participants feel about a training program usually captured through post-training surveys that ask questions like:

Did you enjoy the session?
Was the facilitator engaging?
Was the content useful?

These are often referred to as “smiley sheets” because they gauge satisfaction, not effectiveness. But in today’s context, just liking the training is not enough.

Reimagining Level 1 for Transfer:

To make Level 1 meaningful in driving training transfer effectiveness, we must ask deeper, more purposeful questions:

Are participants motivated to apply what they have learned?
Do they believe the training is relevant to their job?
Can they see how the content connects to performance expectations?
Do they feel supported to use these skills in the real world?

In other words, we are shifting from “Did you like it?” to “Are you ready and willing to use it?”

This reimagined approach transforms Level 1 into a diagnostic tool for understanding the emotional and cognitive readiness of participants to apply what they have learned a critical precursor to behaviour change.

When you evaluate learner mindset, perceived value, and intent to apply, Level 1 becomes a foundation for transfer, not just a formality.

At ITTEC 2025, we are unpacking how to reimagine all four levels of the Kirkpatrick Model. Join global experts as we explore how to design, measure, and support learning that actually transfers.

Let us go from training to transformation together.

#TrainingTransferEffectiveness #KirkpatrickModel #Level1Evaluation #Reaction #LearningAndDevelopment #PerformanceImprovement #BusinessImpact #ITTEC2025 #HRLeadership #HRStrategy #KirkpatrickReimagined #Training #ROI&ROE #WorkplaceLearning #BusinessTransformation #TalentDevelopment

Comments

CELEBRATING TRAINING TRANSFER EFFECTIVENESS CHAMPIONS

Behind every impactful training initiative is a group of people who go the extra mile to make sure training does not just happen — it sticks . These are your Training Transfer Effectiveness Champions (TTE Champions) — the unsung heroes who take what they have learned and apply it consistently to drive change, solve problems, and inspire others. Whether they are team leads reinforcing training, employees practising new skills, or managers coaching their teams post-training, they are the reason training works . Why Recognition Matters It reinforces desired behaviours. Encourages others to follow suit. Builds a culture of learning accountability. Increases motivation for continued application. When you celebrate champions, you send a powerful message: What you do after the training is just as important as attending it. How to Celebrate TTE Champions Highlight real stories of on-the-job application. Give public shout-outs during team meetings or newsletters. Create internal awards for succ...

USING COACHING TO REINFORCE TRAINING TRANSFER EFFECTIVENESS

You have invested in training. Your team has acquired new skills. However… are they applying them? The truth is, training alone does not drive behaviour change — coaching does. While training introduces knowledge, coaching anchors it. It creates the space for reflection, feedback, problem-solving, and sustained application. Why Coaching Matters in the Transfer Journey: Bridges the knowing-doing gap: Coaching helps employees translate theory into action. Encourages accountability: Employees are more likely to follow through when someone checks in. Personalises training: Every employee is different — coaching meets them where they are. Supports habit formation: Through ongoing reinforcement, coaching turns new skills into default behaviour. Promotes confidence: With a safe space to explore and practice, employees grow into their new capabilities. Coaching is not just an L&D add-on — it is a transfer multiplier. Practical Coaching Approaches That Work: Peer Coaching – Set up buddy sy...

INTERNAL PARTNERSHIPS THAT DRIVE RESULTS IN TRAINING TRANSFER EFFECTIVENESS

No matter how well-designed your training is, it will not stick without support from within the organisation. That is because Training Transfer Effectiveness is not a solo sport — it is a team effort that requires strong internal partnerships across departments, roles, and functions. When HR, L&D, line managers, and leadership are aligned, training becomes a shared responsibility, not just a training department initiative. Who Are the Key Internal Partners? Line Managers: They coach, reinforce, and hold employees accountable for applying what they learn. Supervisors & Team Leads: They create day-to-day opportunities for practice and provide real-time feedback. HR Business Partners: They ensure that training goals align with performance expectations and growth pathways. Department Heads: They cascade priorities and embed training into team strategy and KPIs. Executives & Senior Leaders: They sponsor training initiatives, signal strategic importance, and role-model commi...

The Laboratory

Search This Blog